Most Americans are well aware of the recent travails of the US Government in finalizing their federal budget. In making his case for balancing the budget, Obama argued that “every day, families sacrifice to live within their means. They deserve a government that does the same."
However, Ted Rall makes his counter-argument against this myth that American families are thrifty and keen on balancing their personal budgets. In addition to informing us of the facts (the average family has a debt of nearly $11,000), he posits this interesting scenario:
“If consumer credit vanished, the corporato-capitalist system currently prevailing in the U.S. would deteriorate from its current, merely unsustainable form into total chaos. Without credit cards and other loans citizens would seethe, trapped between the mutually irreconcilable forces of falling wages and the aggressive advertising and marketing of products they would never be able to afford. There would only be two possible long-term outcomes: revolution, or the ruling classes would be forced to pay substantially higher wages to workers. To corporate elites, the latter choice would be too unpalatable to countenance.”
Of the two possible outcomes of a credit-free society that Rall discusses, the latter (paying higher wages to workers) is a very intriguing situation. It would undoubtedly cut into the colossal wealth of the top one percent, but the resulting economic justice would provide for a far more acceptable standard of living for the majority.
Such a course of action, I believe, is promoted by the Islamic economic ethos. This is but one example of what the Shariah would provide to its participants – a more just economic system, where capitalistic greed is not given the absolute free reign it has been afforded by modern-day capitalism.
Too bad such intellectual thought exercises are missing from the discussions on Shariah.
Instead, let us continue the fear-mongering and adventures in disinformation. After all, why bother trying to understand the intricate details of Islamic economic jurisprudence when it’s so much easier to simply pass off scary images of bearded Mullahs, honour killings, and dhimmi taxes as wholly representative of Shariah?
The Economics of Shariah
Wednesday, April 27, 2011
Wednesday, April 27, 2011 | Labels: American Islam, capitalism, Islam, Shariah | 5 Comments
Muslims, Shariah, and America
Saturday, April 23, 2011
I just finished reading this CNN piece written my Muslim Comedian, Dean Obeidallah. In it, he addresses the recent GOP-concocted ruckus over the role of Sharia in the US. It’s not the least bit surprising that politicians are using islamophobic rhetoric to stoke the flames of fear among the masses. It’s a tactic that has been successfully used since 9/11.
But what is surprising is the troubling attitude that American Muslims have towards the Sharia. Why are so many Muslims so quick to write off the Sharia as an ideal system for all of humanity? Shouldn’t we be confident that the divine precepts set forth within the Shariah provide what is best for all of mankind?
I understand that due to decades of misinformation, the Shariah is equated with oppression, stoning, and forced conversions. But instead of working to clear up these blatant misconceptions and properly present the beautiful, humane aspects of Islamic law, why are so many of us turning our backs on the Shariah and agreeing with the public sentiment that it has no place in America?
Huh?!
Why have we become so ashamed of the Shariah, like that proverbial crazy uncle whose embarrassing antics make everyone uncomfortable, eventually wishing he would just go away?
After all, if the commandments of Allah (swt) had been in place in America, I am convinced that the catastrophically oppressive system of interest-based banking would not have bound countless struggling families by the economic shackles that have enslaved them to their financial masters.
If the Shariah were implemented in America, hundreds of billions would not have been squandered on the military-industry complex at the cost of healthcare programs, educational reforms, and battling poverty.
If the Shariah ever became a legal reality in America, the beautiful Prophetic axiom “Do not harm and do not reciprocate harm” (La Darara wa La Dirar) would become the overarching principle of America’s foreign policy.
If the Shariah ever found its way into the Supreme Court, carbon emissions, climate change, and other environmental concerns would trump every corporation’s right to grotesque profits.
If the Shariah laws were applied in America, human dignity would return to its proper place above the politically manipulated concept of human freedom.
If the Shariah was the law of the land, universally acknowledged vices such as gambling, alcohol, and pornography would not be sanctioned by the state.
If the Shariah came to be at the national level, economic hitmen and corporate jackals, with the support of the American government, would not freely roam the earth looking for lands to rape and populations to fleece.
The Shariah covers all aspects of human life and contrary to the picture some American Muslims are presenting about the Shariah, it is NOT restricted to one’s personal life. It provides guidelines for politics and economics, international relations and domestic policies, scientific research and spiritual purification, social relations from the nuclear family all the way to the global level.
It does away with man’s arrogant proclamation that he knows what is best for him. Verily, his Creator knows better.
So, I would boldly declare that I am a strong proponent of the Shariah becoming established not only in America, but throughout the world. Just allow me the time and respect to explain what that entails.
Saturday, April 23, 2011 | Labels: American Islam, Muslims, Shariah | 18 Comments
Criminalize War?
Tuesday, November 3, 2009
I scoff at the mere suggestion, reminding myself of the various injunctions of Allah (swt) and His messenger (saw) that not only make certain forms of combat necessary, but commendable. How can any sane Muslim ever consider all forms of war to be criminal, especially when our Creator has stated, "Fighting is prescribed upon you and you dislike it. However, it may be that you dislike a thing which is good for you..."(2:216)?
The Prophet took part in many battles and he surely was no criminal! So who are we to suggest that war become a criminal act, worthy of universal condemnation?
Of course, when I bring up the criminality of war as discussed in contemporary forums, I am looking at it less from secular, international standards and more from Islamic juristic rulings. So, in reality, my question may be better phrased - Should war be Haram?
My concern arises from a recent talk given by Mahathir Mohammad on the call to criminalize war (YouTube link).
While he didn't express any earth-shattering points in his short talk, it struck me while listening that war in the 21st century is entirely different from how warfare was conducted in the past. So maybe it *is* time that we reconsider the Islamic ruling on war as its carried out in this day and age.
After all, Muslims universally reject modern-day slavery - not because slavery never existed in Islamic history, but because the form in which it has been practiced in recent history is abominable and would have been deemed inhumane and clearly Haram by our beloved Prophet (saw).
Why can't the same logic be applied to modern warfare?
After giving it some thought, I seriously believe that our perfect model Muhammad (saw) would reject all forms of modern warfare. The indiscriminate killing by missiles and drones, the unfathomable harm caused by multi-ton bombs, the ability to destroy an entire nation in a matter of hours, environmental damage beyond control - all stand in stark contrast to every teaching of the Prophetic concept of war.
Surely some will counter with the verse in the Quran "Make ready against them whatever force and war mounts you are able to muster, so that you might deter thereby the enemies of God" (8:60) as a justification to using modern military equipment, including nuclear.
But the problem with the nuclear deterrence argument is that one must be fully prepared to make good on one's threat. And Islamically, I'm just not comfortable with that possibility.
On the other hand, I understand that traditional scholars, such as Abu Hanifa, justified the usage of flooding or poisoning water sources as legitimate tools in war. But c'mon, the scope of such tactics pale in comparison to the ridiculous damage that can be inflicted by the military arsenal at our disposal in the 21st century.
No, I haven't become a pacifist. I firmly believe that force is necessary to bring about justice and truth. It's just that the current form in which this force is wielded has got me thinking twice about its permissibility in our deen.
Tuesday, November 03, 2009 | Labels: Islam, Jihad, Shariah | 7 Comments
GNP: Female Shariah Court Judge
Friday, May 15, 2009
When I read the story below, I felt it was special enough to revive my Good News Post series.
The Christian Science Monitor has this excellent article covering Judge Khouloud el-Faqeeh who is the very first Qadiyah (female judge) in Palestine.
While there are many female judges all over the Muslim world, she is believed to be one of the first female judges for Shariah-based courts.
Now, I wonder if the same people who sensationalized the case of the singular Saudi judge who condoned slapping of the wife are going to overplay this story in a similar manner?
I don't think so.
I wonder why.
Friday, May 15, 2009 | Labels: Good News Post, Muslims, Palestine, Shariah | 4 Comments
Pakistan
Monday, May 11, 2009
I've kept quiet over the past few weeks with all this crap flying around about the countless problems plaguing Pakistan. But I really need to let out some steam.
It's such BS how the image of Pakistan succumbing to extremist forces is being paraded around in the MSM. This recent piece* by a NY Times writer really set me off.
The main themes you'll find in most reports are these three:
"Oh my, look at how close the Taliban forces have gotten to Islamabad - only 100 miles away!"
"The Pakistani nukes are in danger of falling into the hands of Al-Qaeda."
"Pakistan has given up control by signing over the Swat valley to the Shariah. The Shariah is taking over the world! "
Outright fear mongering at its worst.
Look, I'm no fan of the Pakistani government. They are crooks to the highest degree. They've stolen from the population as well as from the international community. Shame on them and shame on the world for continuing to support them.
And I'm also no fan of the nation of Pakistan, as so many Pakistani nationalists who live and die for the nation. Zaid Hamid is one character who at first impressed me, but recently I'm getting very tired of his pro-Pakistani, pro-army stance riddled with Zionist and Indian paranoia. These folks have gone off the deep end, referring to Pakistani forces as the real mujahideen.
But let's get real here folks. Pakistan is (and sadly always will be) the same useless country of corrupt feudal lords and army generals. The country is not losing control to anyone. The army is the seventh largest in the world. They have an established federal infrastructure with semi-stable governmental services. Police run the streets, not gangs or warlords. Legal cases are settled in courts, not by local mafias.
So what's with all this propaganda painting Pakistan with the same brush as failed states Afghanistan and Somalia?
First, I'm convinced the powers-that-be desire for a more controllable Pakistan. And the best way to achieve said desire is to either break it up or declare it a failed state. Both options would result in an outside presence needed to oversee the nation.
The other possibility is along the lines of Pepe Escobar's theory that all eyes are on the main prize: resource-rich Baluchistan. This theory includes the chess-game going on between the US, Russia, and China.
Regardless of the various theories posited to explain the outside presence, it's painfully clear that America is screwing things up, what with the careless drone bombings and the recent findings of them using white-phosphorous.
And that's why I love how this picture of a US soldier in Afghanistan perfectly sums up America's poorly planned presence in Af-Pak. Just like this fool who didn't consider using a weight clip to hold the plates. Idiot.
It's really too bad that so much international politics is hamstringing this region. I really would've liked to have seen how far the Afghan Taliban could have gone with their project from the late 90's.
======
*The author basically served as a mouthpiece for the liberal elites of Pakistan. Fearful of losing their lavish secular lifestyles, they're coming up with this crap:
"All the world's achievements for the past 500 years are at risk"
"Once you bring Islam into politics, it's hard to handle..You don't have the tools to control it."
For them (Islamists) "laughter is not permitted, not even a full smile"
"This is really a war for the soul of Pakistan"
Huh? You mean the soul of Pakistan was never threatened by the gross economic disparity that you thrive off of? The soul of Pakistan was never threatened by the institutionalized cronyism fueled by your greed? Ya, it's just now that some folks up north are fed up with the ineffective local government and are calling for Shariah courts that you fear for the soul of Pakistan.
Get real you losers.
Monday, May 11, 2009 | Labels: Pakistan, Shariah, Taliban | 10 Comments
The Absurdity of Islamic Banking
Friday, April 10, 2009
It all started with my Saudi co-worker telling me how his wife reminds him of a GMC Suburban.
Odd, I thought to myself, I never considered it a compliment to describe one's wife as an oversized SUV, but hey, different folks, different strokes.
He continued by explaining the odyssey of his marriage, which began as it does for many youth - in need of money. But since the Shariah compliant banks don't offer straight up cash loans, he had to take a popular, alternative route.
He went to a dealership and financed the Suburban (valued at around 100,000 riyals) over a 5 year payment period. He explained how outside the dealership there are individuals with 'bags of money' waiting to buy your newly purchased vehicle (of course at a discounted rate).
The dealer sold the car, the middle man made his pretty profit, and best of all, my friend got the cash he needed to help him get married. Perfect!
Not really, I thought. Although each transaction is permissible in Islam, the entire transaction wreaks of a straight-up money for money loan (read: Riba) with the commodity (in this case the Suburban) thrown in as a mere formality.
But wait, it gets even better.
There are some banks here in Saudi that are using steel as the commodity in order to give out loans. It's the same as the example of the Suburban, except that man standing outside the parking lot with the money is taken out of the equation. The bank conveniently replaces him, ending up as both the seller and the buyer, all in order to allow you to get a halal cash loan.
Here's how their magic works: You walk into the bank needing say 50,000 riyals. The bank sells you 50,000 worth of steel for 60,000 over 5 years. Then they buy it back from you for 50,000. You walk out of the bank with 50,000 in hand and a debt of 60,000 to be paid over 5 years.
In fact, my friend told me that the steel actually does exist, in some warehouse outside Riyadh, in order to comply with the Shariah board's requirement. Someone he knows actually wanted to go out to see the steel in order to verify the 'validity' of the transaction and sure enough, the warehouse was there, full of steel. Some worker over there actually laughed how no one has ever come to visit the premises since its creation several years ago.
But I digress.
Now I'll be the first to admit that there are few topics as daunting, complex, and mysterious as Islamic finance - astrophysics and female psychology are two that immediately come to mind. But even I can understand that one of the fundamental principles of Islamic finance is that money can't be made from money. The Islamic economic system is a commodity-based system - transactions are based on buying and selling goods, not buying and selling money.
How in the world can these people convince themselves that they're partaking in a halal transaction?
In the end, I shake my head and think how fitting that a society that has made a sham of Islamic morality, has done the same to Islamic economics.
So is it just me or does anyone else see the eerie similarities between the actions described above and the actions of Bani Israel when they left their fishing nets out on the Sabbath, and returned the next day in order to collect the fish?
Both adhered to the letter of the law, while flaunting the spirit of the law.
===========
UPDATE: I did some more research and found that Saudi scholars have not sanctioned the second type of transaction, where the bank sells the commodity and then buys it back. However, they have approved of the first example (where the SUV is sold to a guy outside the bank).
Nonetheless, many banks in KSA perform both types of transaction, banking (pun intended) on the customer's ignorance of the fatwa details.
That being said, I still find it extremely questionable that I can walk into a bank, finance some steel (or rice or whatever) that everyone knows I will never use, and then walk out and sell it for straight up cash. Although it complies with all the Shariah requirements, it reminds me of the saying: If it walks like a duck and talks like a duck...
Friday, April 10, 2009 | Labels: capitalism, Islam, life in Saudi Arabia, Muslims, Shariah | 11 Comments
Worshipping with Water
Sunday, March 29, 2009
In the face of gripping news like the AIG fiasco, the Pakistan masjid bombing, the Madonna adoption drama, and so on, its important to sometimes sit back and focus on the more simpler things in life.
This is one of those times.
I was attending a class on Fiqh and the teacher went on a rant on how Muslims have lost sight of the Sunnah when it comes to water consumption. He mentioned how the Prophet (saw) used to make wudu with a single bowl of water (!) and take a bath with 4-5 bowls worth (!!).
And here we are, completely ignorant of the immense amount of water being wasted through our own actions.
This is not about environmentalism and becoming 'Green'. This is not about global water shortages.
This is about the spirit of the Sunnah. The Prophet (saw) taught us to conserve water even when water is abundant (like a running stream).
This is about rejecting the frame of mind that sees the world through purely utilitarian lenses and instead tuning into the frequency of the cosmos.
This is about ceasing to view water simply as a compound of two hydrogens and one oxygen and beginning to see it as a most fundamental element of Allah's creation.
This is about realizing that water is a blessing, just like our wealth and our health, and is not to be misused, abused, or overused.
So what did the teacher suggest? Nothing sensational - just common sense stuff:
1. When you brush your teeth, turn the water off. No need to keep it running.
2. Try bathing yourself with a bucket of water. It consumes much less water than a typical shower. However, if that's too difficult, turn the shower off when you're lathering yourself with soap. No need to keep it running.
3. Perform your wudu with a trickle of water. No need to run the faucet at full blast.
4. Stop taking a shower every single day. Well, not all of you. But most people don't get so dirty and stinky that they need to shower every day. Skipping a day here or there for the sake of conserving water would truly be a good deed. Again, this may not be true for all of you (you know who you are).
With the proper intention, these steps can all become beautiful acts of worship.
And indeed, Allah (swt) is Most Merciful and Generous in rewarding His servant.
Sunday, March 29, 2009 | Labels: Islam, Muslims, Shariah | 13 Comments
Islamists preventing girls' education
Monday, March 2, 2009
Allow me to begin with two anecdotal tales:
1.) I was talking to my son's second grade teacher from last year and he told me about a Pakistani national curriculum project he's working on, commissioned by one of Pakistan's largest publishing houses, Ferozsons Ltd. The Pakistani government, he told me, had hired some consultants from Germany to revamp their nationwide curriculum in attempts to modernize archaic teachings found in their outdated education system.
They submitted their proposal and one of the members of some governmental board wasn't too happy with the additions, which included subjects such as the celebration of Diwali (Hindu holiday) as well as taboo topics such as dating. This eventually led to Ferozsons getting involved and hiring my friend.
2.) My wife's friend teaches at King Saud University here in Riyadh at a newly opened English prep program that has been subcontracted to a British educational company. Their textbooks (and I read them myself) are filled with references to pop culture completely foreign to local Saudi culture (dance clubs, mixed social gatherings, Britney Spears, Bruce Springsteen, and many more cultural icons).
I was floored by the blatant message being pushed in their texts. It wasn't even subtle. Conversations discussing Xmas parties and social mixers. Vocabulary focused on attire specific to western society (tank tops, shorts, etc.).
I figured that since the program is new, the school administration hasn't gotten the chance to review the material, but boy was this stuff explosive. I would seriously have a difficult time exposing my children to such cultural propaganda (the Disney channel is bad enough).
I share with you these two tales to introduce my post on censoring education, especially as is being practiced in Pakistan/Afghanistan.
I'm seriously beginning to get upset with Muslims so callously denouncing the actions of ultra-orthodox traditionalists in the tribal areas of Pakistan - all based solely on the media's misrepresentation. But its a bit too much when respected teachers in the (online) community take a public stance without due diligence in getting all the facts.
For sure, I haven't traveled to northern Pakistan and gotten all the details, but based on my limited experience and personal reactions to disturbing trends in Western educational material being presented to our children, I can *begin* to understand what drastic measures an uber-conservative people (as found in Pakistan and Afghanistan) would carry out in order to counter such garbage.
Let's keep these factors in mind when reading about stories on girls education in northern Pakistan/Afghanistan:
1. These places are extremely poverty-ridden. The dynamics of such a society differs from ours. Education, for both sexes, is not necessarily seen as a way out of poverty. The boys normally drop out in order to help the family make ends meet, while the girls end up either staying home to help the extended family or they get married off. So when the school is seen as a source of questionable teachings, introducing thoughts and practices not only foreign to the society but antithetical to it, the result is a closing down of the schools.
2. The tension in the north of Pakistan has less to do with implementing Islam and more to do with the failure of the Pakistan government. The insurgency has used Talibanization as its vehicle to counter the gross incompetency of the national leadership. Sadly, education, seen as a propaganda tool for passing along the government's curriculum, is collateral damage in this war.
3. The other side of the story as told by the pro-Taliban folks is that the schools being blown up by them are in reality being used as base camps by the Pakistani army. They aren't targeting schools in order to shut them down, but as military tactics in their battle against Pakistani forces.
4. There is a major propaganda war going against militant Islam and one of the main weapons against them is the issue of educating girls. Just as apostasy, honor killings and FGM (Female Genital Mutilation) were the favorite topics of yesteryear, girls education is the hot topic of today in countering Islamism.
Such sensationalism is so widespread that CNN has even ascribed shutting down girls schools to the recent implementation of Shariah in Somalia. Such a phenomenon (of preventing girls from attending school) was never advocated under the Islamic Courts nor has the more radical Shabab ever promoted it. CNN's attempt at cross-over demonizing is pure disinformation at its best.
So before we start criticizing these movements in Afghanistan and Pakistan for taking away the God-given right of education, let us introduce some perspective into our dialogue as well as get our facts straight.
Are you an Extremist?
Friday, February 27, 2009
The Guardian tells us of a leaked document from the UK government detailing their counter-terrorism strategy on isolating extremists in the Muslim community. The interesting part is where it details on how they qualify extremists:
"People would be considered as extremists if:
• They advocate a caliphate, a pan-Islamic state encompassing many countries.
• They promote Sharia law.
• They believe in jihad, or armed resistance, anywhere in the world. This would include armed resistance by Palestinians against the Israeli military.
• They argue that Islam bans homosexuality and that it is a sin against Allah.
• They fail to condemn the killing of British soldiers in Iraq or Afghanistan."
And from the looks of it, the defining characteristics are nothing new in this post 9-11 climate in which we find ourselves. Many of these qualifying traits have been used to describe extremists from day one of the war on terror, so its simply more of the same.
However, it does help us to see the long-term agenda in suppressing any form of political Islam. Its clear they wish for us to demarcate between religion and state thereby adopting secularism as an ideology.
And to boot, we mustn't support the defeat of their occupying, imperialistic ways!
What a sweet deal!
Now I don't agree with so much of the methodology adopted by many Islamists who advocate a global caliphate or the Jihadis fighting the US/UK forces in Iraq and Afghanistan. But I will never compromise my belief in the principles they are struggling for.
Am I wrong to believe that the majority of Muslims agree with me? The majority wants to live by the laws of the Quran and Sunna. The majority believes in Jihad as an essential component of Islam. The majority believe homosexuality is haram. The majority believe the foreign forces in Iraq and Afghanistan must leave.
Is it too much to ask that they understand the nuance between the majority of Muslims who believe in these basic Islamic principles and the minority who are going about achieving their goals in an unacceptable manner?
So basically, UK is telling us that for us to become accepted members of their society, we have to sell out on some of our basic principles.
No to Jihad, No to Sharia, No to Khilafa, and Yes to Homosexuality.
Yaay! Where do I sign up?
Friday, February 27, 2009 | Labels: American Islam, Islamic State, Shariah, war on terror | 15 Comments
Last post on Taliban/Shabab...for now
Monday, February 2, 2009
Not to belabor the point from my previous post, but I wanted to share one more thought on our very telling relationship with groups like the Taliban or Al-Shabab. I'll start by quoting from a Jonathan Lyons piece over at Juan Cole's site:
"Central to this narrative (referring to Huntington's clash of civilization theory) is a series of familiar ideas across the political arena, on the Internet, on talk radio, in the mainstream media, and, all too frequently, in academia. Such notions include: Islam is a religion of violence; ... Muslims are “medieval” and fearful of modernity; Muslims are sexually perverse – either lascivious polygamists, repressive misogynists, or both; and, finally, they are caught up in a jealous rage at the West’s failure to value them or their beliefs.
Today, such assertions still echo: We love liberty, They hate freedom; We are rational, They are not; We are modern, They are medieval; We are good, They are evil."
The West (and Western Muslims who have fallen for their empty rhetoric) needs to constantly prop up and tear down the actions of groups that feed the above stereotypes. It's no coincidence that the exact qualities that Lyons lists above are the qualities that are constantly publicized in media reports demonizing these groups.
They are the Lex Luthor to our Superman. This narrative is so W Bush and we've got to move beyond it. Our analysis must be properly informed and respectfully objective.
For starters, if you want a fresh perspective on the Taliban as they exist in north Pakistan, this Asia Times Online series is a good place to start. The reporter tries to present a balanced view of the situation.
Sadly, too many will find it long and boring. Quick soundbites reporting the closing of girl schools or lashing of criminals are much sexier.
Monday, February 02, 2009 | Labels: East meets West, Pakistan, politics, Shabab, Shariah, Taliban | 3 Comments
Taliban, Shabab, and Tigers, Oh My!
Saturday, January 31, 2009
It's time we inject some much-needed perspective into our discussions of groups like the Taliban and Somalia's Al-Shabab. Too many Muslims living in the West have gotten sucked into the efforts to demonize these groups. While I'm not here to defend them, I must clearly state that I don't believe they are evil, as some fellow bloggers have declared them to be.
Sure, these groups are peddling a version of Islam that is foreign to our sensibilities (as reported by Western media) - enforcing the hudood, restricting women's rights, oppressing minorities, etc.
However, it just seems that so many of us are bending over backwards in denouncing these "deviant" groups to appease our compatriots. In either trying to prove our allegiance to liberal, democratic ideals or establishing our credentials in the ongoing war on terror, we're ok with the collateral damage caused by throwing these groups under the bus. All the while conveniently overlooking the societal context in which they came to existence - extreme warlordism, civil war, foreign occupation, rampant crime and rape, and so on.
For all the negative hoopla surrounding these groups, people forget one most essential consideration: they have succeeded where countless others have failed - establishing peace and stability. Western media is quick to focus on the undoubtedly extremist views they impart, but overlooks a more critical benefit that is welcomed by the local population - peace of mind.
My father traveled to Afghanistan back in the 90's as part of a medical support team and the overwhelming sentiment shared by the population was their collective sigh of relief with the safety situation established by the Taliban. After years of war with Russia and the ensuing warlord-based government, the Afghan on the street was finally able to feel some sense of safety and security. Sure, many didn't take kindly to the harsh interpretation of Islamic law, but they found that a small price to pay for a relatively crime-free, stable society.
Exactly the same feelings were expressed by Marian Zeila, chairperson of the Somali Media Women's Association, in this BBC report:
"Sharia law is a part of Islam, it's in the Koran. But it's their interpretation of the law that I disagree with. They are turning Islam into a harsh religion, which I don't believe it actually is...While the transitional government was in charge there was insecurity in Baidoa, they were unable to protect civilians. At least the al-Shabab have restored stability - for the time being."
So before we decide to get on our high horses and offer up our knee-jerk condemnations of these groups for misrepresenting or distorting Islam, let us try and understand the socio-political context of their rise. Or at the very least, as some have suggested, let's simply leave them alone.
Saturday, January 31, 2009 | Labels: Africa, East meets West, Shabab, Shariah, Taliban, war on terror | 12 Comments
Somalia: Another Failure of Politial Islam
Saturday, January 17, 2009
So the latest news coming out of Somalia is that as Ethopian troops are moving out, in-fighting has begun between the moderate Ahlus Sunna wal Jamaat and the more extreme Al-Shabab. Al-Shabab is accusing the Ahlus Sunna group of being warlords, while the Ahlus Sunna accuses Al-Shabab of being foreign fighters sympathizing with Al-Qaeda.
And then there are unsubstantiated reports that the UIC (Islamic Courts) are in battle with the Shabab.
Eerily similar to what happened in Afghanistan after Russia pulled out.
Here we go again. Sigh.
It's quite confusing trying to sort out fact from fiction, truth from propaganda, but my understanding is that most Somalis are moderates with links to Sufism, so they aren't very welcoming of the firebrand version of Islam enforced by Al-Shabab. I recently saw a lengthy interview on Al-Jazeera with one of their leaders and while he seemed sincere, humble, and committed to Islam, he was parroting the Al-Qaeda sales pitch which definitely won't go over well with many Somalis.
But let us look at the bigger picture and agree that such militant movements are really incapable in achieving the real goal of Shariah. The level of adherence to the laws of Allah (swt) in the societal level are merely a reflection of the adherence to those laws on a personal level. The Shariah can never be implemented through the barrel of a gun or the casting of a ballot - it must come via the transformation of the hearts.
I wrote about this before:
And therefore, as a blessing to us (as well as the rest of world), Allah (swt) has placed a political straitjacket on the Ummah – preventing it from tasting any political power so as to prevent it from causing any harm unto others or to itself.
As a blessing to us (and the rest of world), we will continue to see failed political/military efforts for establishing Muslim states or electing Muslim leaders (Algeria, Sudan, Somalia, Afghanistan, Hamas, Anwar Ibrahim).
Allah (swt) will either send the Americans or a military junta or the Ethiopians or the Israelis or even a 23-year-old political aide, but the results will be the same – no power for the Muslims.
We simply are not ready for the immensely grave responsibility of being representatives of the Most High (khalifat-Allah).
As I see it, I refuse to place a gun in my child's hands. Similarly, Allah (swt) has refused to place power in the Ummah's hands.
That's why Islamic political parties (as found in Turkey, Malaysia, Palestine) will never succeed. Nor will militant groups (as found in Somalia and Afghanistan). Sure they may bring about short-term relief in repelling occupying forces, but they will never succeed in the long-term.
Not until the hearts of the masses begin to respect the words of Allah (swt) and the practice of His beloved Prophet (saw).
Saturday, January 17, 2009 | Labels: Africa, Islamic State, Muslims, Pakistan, Palestine, Shariah, Spirituality | 12 Comments
