Naeem's Blog

An odd mix of Islam, politics, and off-the-wall news as seen by an American Muslim living in limbo.

  • Entries
  • Comments

  • HOME
  • About Me
  • Email Me
Showing posts with label democracy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label democracy. Show all posts

Ghannouchi on Islam and Secularism

Thursday, March 29, 2012


I recently came across this interesting presentation on Islam and Secularism by Tunisian intellectual Rashid Ghannouchi.  Tunisia is at a critical juncture, having just elected an Islamically-inclined party, Ennehda, to power after having successfully staged their revolution that went on to spark the Arab Spring. And Ghannouchi is the intellectual head of this movement.

I have read some of his works written in years past when he was in exile and so I was looking forward to his perspective after having finally achieved a platform for implementing his vision. Unfortunately, I came away greatly disappointed in what I felt to be a grossly apologetic approach to synchronizing the paradox of Islam and Secularism.

I’ve taken snippets from his talk followed by my comments. However, in order to taste the full complement of flavors experienced in his talk, you really must read it from beginning to end.

=-=-=

“Secularism appeared, evolved, and crystallized in the West as procedural solutions, and not as a philosophy or theory of existence, to problems that had been posed in the European context. Most of these problems emerged following the Protestant split in the West, which tore apart the consensus that had been dominant in the Catholic Church, and imposed the religious wars in the 16th and 17th century. It was thus that Secularism and/or secularization began.”

Secularism is not simply a set of ‘procedural solutions’. How could a set of mere ‘procedural solutions’ have been proposed to clean up the mess made by the religious wars of the 16th and 17th centuries? One needs only to look back at the embryonic stages of secularism and study the environment in which it was gestated to realize that the Reformation, the Renaissance, Enlightenment and other deeply philosophical events were key in the formulation of Western Secularism.

Europe needed an entirely different mindset and worldview in order to overwrite centuries of damage caused by the paternalistic Church. And thus, Secularism conveniently separated the over-reaching arm of the Church from the state and declared all religious matters divorced from the public realm.  No ‘procedural solutions’ could have ever achieved such a monumental paradigm shift.

True, secularism has a procedural component, such as the significance of rule of law or the separation of powers, but to suggest that it isn’t a philosophy or that it doesn’t strongly promote and encourage a certain theory of existence (i.e. atheism) is patently incorrect.

“In the United States religious interference in the public domain is evident, despite the differentiation that exists there remains a significant religious influence. Their leaders' speeches are laden with religious content and references, and religion is debated in all electoral campaigns where it manifests itself in issues such as prayer in schools and abortion.”

To argue that the US intermixes religion and politics in issues of any substance is naïve.  The rare sprinkling of religion into the political realm is superficial at best.  The role of religion in core governance issues is nonexistent. The fact that religion is allowed a chair at the table of government is merely a PR ploy.  Only peripheral issues, such as abortion, contraception, and prayer in school, are regularly marched before the public (coincidentally during election season), so as to distract from the more vital issues such as social services , foreign policy, economics, etc.

“This will naturally lead to a diversity in interpretation, and there is no harm in that except when we need to legislate, at which time we are in need of a mechanism, and the best mechanism that mankind has come up with is the electoral and democratic one which produces representatives of the nation and makes these interpretations a collective as opposed to an individual effort.”

Based on what is he able to declare that the best legislative mechanism that mankind has come up with is the electoral and democratic one?  With so many apparent abuses and failures of the democratic methodology, how can this be the best mankind has devised? It is folly at best, and disingenuous misrepresentation at worst, to suggest that a republic based on democratic procedures can most optimally yield a just and fair government. Have not centuries of this exact political experiment in Europe and the US proven that all democracies inevitably spiral downwards into the sewage of plutocracy and oligarchy? Why are we so in a rush to duplicate the failures of our masters?

“But if what is mean is the separation in the French sense or in accordance with the Marxist experience then we may engage in a dangerous adventure that may harm both religion and state. The total stripping of the state from religion would turn the state into a mafia, and the world economic system into an exercise in plundering, and politics into deception and hypocrisy. And this is exactly what happened in the Western experience, despite there being some positive aspects. International politics became the preserve of a few financial brokers owning the biggest share of capital and by extension the media, through which they ultimately control politicians.”

The speaker has failed to provide any alternate method by which a secular democracy can be employed without inevitably resulting in the above-mentioned negative after-effects.

“There is no value to any religious observance that is motivated through coercion. It is of no use to turn those who are disobedient to God into hypocrites through the state's coercive tools. People are created free and while it is possible to have control over their external aspects, it is impossible to do so over their inner selves and convictions.”

This is a typical red herring by the pro-secularism side and while I expect such misleading drivel from the likes of Bush, I am very disappointed to read it from Ghannouchi.  They paint a binary landscape in which complete freedom of religion exists solely in a setting where religion plays a minimal role in governance or religion and politics mix into a toxic potion resulting in coercion and compulsion by oppressive religious state authorities.

No one is arguing for state interference in private religious matters.  No one wishes for the state to have control over ‘their inner selves and convictions.’ It isn’t a choice of absolute liberalism or absolute authoritarianism.

“The state's duty, however, is to provide services to people before anything else, to create job opportunities, and to provide good health and education not to control people's hearts and minds.”

What about creating a rich, fertile society in which man can fully express his humanity, which happens to be through adherence to the Quran and Sunnah.

“For this reason, I have opposed the coercion of people in all its forms and manifestation and have dealt with such controversial topics such as al-Riddah (apostasy) and have defended the freedom of people to either adhere to or defect from a religious creed, based on the Qur'anic verse that says: 'there is no compulsion in religion'.”

Sadly he shows his limited understanding of the ideal mix between religion and politics when he restricts his samples to the media-mandated hot topics of veiling and apostasy.

These are all straw men, propped up and consequently shot down by him to simply further his pro-secularism contentions. No sane advocate of combining religion and politics is suggesting that the state must force religiosity on its citizens.  Rather, the state must cultivate an environment conducive to carrying out one’s religious obligations while enriching one’s spiritual development.

“This is why Muslims consider Islam's proof to be so powerful that there is no need to coerce people, and when the voice of Islam proclaims 'Produce your proof if ye are truthful' this challenge is being proposed at the heart of the political and intellectual conflict.”

Again, the argument isn’t about coercing citizens to observe religious rituals.  It is about enacting religious principles in state institutions.  It is about removing predatory capitalism from the economy.  It is about instilling a more just foreign policy, in line with the Quran and Sunnah. It is about educating the masses away from materialism and back towards a more spiritual worldview

“The fact that our revolution has succeeded in toppling a dictator, we ought to accept the principle of citizenship, and that this country does not belong to one party or another but rather to all of its citizens regardless of their religion, sex, or any other consideration. Islam has bestowed on them the right to be citizens enjoying equal rights, and to believe in whatever they desire within the framework of mutual respect, and observance of the law which is legislated for by their representatives in parliament.”

And all this can only be achieved via a secular democracy?  Is our intellectual capital so exhausted that we cannot even consider an alternative Islamically-anchored possibility?

Thursday, March 29, 2012 | Labels: American Islam, clash of civilizations, democracy, Islamic State, politics |   7 Comments  

Obama, Imran Khan, and the Materialistic Worldview

Saturday, January 21, 2012

When most of us hear the term Materialism we probably imagine fancy cars, expensive vacations, and credit cards maxed to the limit. Or the more philosophical amongst us will immediately think of the dictionary definition which states that reality is based only upon matter. But the materialistic outlook on life isn’t merely limited to worldly indulgences and matter-based philosophies.  It’s much more insidious when the materialistic worldview seeps into our subconsious.

More specifically, I’m referring to entire cause-and-effect mindset and how the entire human race has effectively embraced it as a fundamental doctrine. Science, the New Age god of the religiously disinclined, has stated that everything in this world operates on the cause-and-effect model. This isn’t limited to the laboratories, but has found its way in everything we say and do.  

Our sustenance comes not from our Creator, but from our monthly paychecks. 
Our success comes not from our adherence to our principles, but from our efforts and struggles. 
We have becomes slaves not of our Lord, but of this materialistic worldview.

And so, when we decide to stand up and struggle for the truth in the face of tyranny and oppression, we find ourselves restricted to ‘proven’ tactics and ‘established’ movements. We must determine the odds of victory and evaluate the calculus of success.  We must choose pragmatism over idealism.  We must compromise and concede for that is the way of the accomplished high priests of the material world.  Our models of success are no more founded on the anachronistic ways of the Prophets, but on the avant-garde techniques of today’s global leaders.

So it is when we finally see a breath of 'fresh' air in our political worlds, we see cause for celebration. We have inexplicably convinced ourselves that political success can only come in the form of a political party that is born from the same decrepit system that has been plaguing and ruining our societies.

The examples set forth by our beloved Prophets, we tell ourselves, are strictly limited to the spiritual realm.  Any issues we may have with our political or economic existence must be dealt with tried and tested methodologies extracted from our textbooks and institutions.  To suggest that the spiritual world can interoperate in the political is extreme folly. At least, that is what the secular materialists have taught us so effectively.

We are so affixed to the cause-and-effect model that we have lost sight of the power of our Lord. With the 'unparalleled power' of our modern minds, an ark in the middle of the desert would be foolish, escaping from a ruthless army and fleeing towards the ocean would be mad, and 313 would never, ever defeat 1000. We have convinced ourselves (or have become convinced) that the only way to victory is by our efforts, not by our principles and beliefs.

Thus, instead of sticking to our principles and looking to our religion for guidance, we rejoice when political idealists such as Obama or Pakistan’s Imran Khan tantalize us with their flowery promises of hope and change. We naively see in them a means of rectifying our broken system. Instead of realizing that never did a Prophet make change from within the broken system, we blindly pursue success with political parties.

Would a Prophet ever submit himself to the evil machinations of modern-day democracy by leading a political party?

It matters not, for those Prophetic examples set forth in our Holy Book are to be read strictly for spiritual blessings, not for any practical application.

Sadly materialism is alive and well, even in the more spiritually inclined amongst us.

Saturday, January 21, 2012 | Labels: democracy, Muslims, Obama, Pakistan, politics, Spirituality |   12 Comments  

The Awlaki Killing

Thursday, October 6, 2011

I won’t go into all the details as I believe the various talking points have been discussed and presented.  Those of you who are regular readers will know where I stand on the issue.  For all others, I simply sat that he shouldn’t have been targeted.  He should have had his day in court.  

I would only add that Muslims should not be so quick to throw out the baby with the bath water.  While he may have adopted abhorrent views that are clearly antithetical to our religion, his previous works that brought countless young Muslims back to the folds of Islam should never be discounted or disregarded. 

On the subject of his more fiery political views that he advocated after his release from Yemeni incarceration, Muslims must be get a backbone and be willing to acknowledge the truth regardless of who says it.  He was very forceful in stating his views against the US Empire that some Muslims in the West were simply not comfortable hearing; and so this group felt no qualm in throwing him and his entire message under the bus.

That was unfortunate because there are too few Muslim voices out there with the necessary level of stinging criticism.  If only we Muslims had such a voice – courageous enough to denounce the Pharaoh of our day and disciplined enough to adhere to the Prophetic way.

----

Despite all this mess of constitutional interpretations and legal wrangling over the targeting of an American citizen, what really upsets me is this tidbit of Obama’s unforthcoming approach to the whole process: 

“But the actual legal reasoning the Department of Justice used to authorize the strike? It's secret. Classified. Information that the public isn't permitted to read, mull over, or challenge.

Why? What justification can there be for President Obama and his lawyers to keep secret what they're asserting is a matter of sound law? This isn't a military secret. It isn't an instance of protecting CIA field assets, or shielding a domestic vulnerability to terrorism from public view. This is an analysis of the power that the Constitution and Congress' post September 11 authorization of military force gives the executive branch. This is a president exploiting official secrecy so that he can claim legal justification for his actions without having to expose his specific reasoning to scrutiny.”
[Source]

So not only is the supposed evidence against Imam Awlaki being kept secret and hidden, but now even the legal reasoning and jurisprudential methodology on which the case is built upon has become a state secret?!

Wow.

What a stretch.

How much further can the government flaunt the very principles they are supposedly fighting for?  And to think, we all thought it couldn’t get any worse than Bush and Cheney.

Thursday, October 06, 2011 | Labels: American Islam, democracy, Obama, politics, war on terror |   2 Comments  

Egypt’s Future: Look to Turkey, Pakistan

Sunday, February 13, 2011

Now that Mubarak has decided to buy a Winnebago and cruise the streets of Sharm el-Sheikh, Egyptians can look forward to a democratic future. And if they wish to look deeper into the crystal ball and see where they’re heading, they needn’t look any further than Turkey and Pakistan.

Both of these heavily-populated pillars of the Muslim world have made bumpy transitions to a democratic system. However, these democracies survive not on any constitutionally-based principle, but on the mercy of the paternalistic, over-bearing military.

The Egyptian masses may eventually ‘wield the power’ to determine which crooked politician is the lesser of two evils, but Gold help them if they attempt to voice their frustrations on economic inequalities or a more just foreign policy. This is the dominion of the powerful elites and normal people are not allowed to meddle therein.

In the same manner that I give my son the freedom to choose his meal from a restaurant’s menu, stepping in when I feel that he’s getting out of control and too dessert-happy, the military has generously afforded the citizenry of these three Muslim nations the freedoms to choose from a political menu of controlled choices, ready to pounce in when the masses get too free with their freedoms.

After all folks, self-determination for the uncivilized has its limitations.

Egyptians can look forward to periods of civilian rule interrupted by military intervention whenever America the military elite feel the nation is headed in a direction antithetical to their private interests.

And that, my friends, is the future of Egypt: controlled democracy.

Undoubtedly it’s better than oppressive autocratic rule.

But why must our ceiling remain so low?

Sunday, February 13, 2011 | Labels: democracy, Egypt, politics |   6 Comments  

Americanism

Monday, March 29, 2010

Pilger is spot on with his definition of Americanism, especially the final sentence about a popular culture designed to distract and stultify the masses:

"Norman Mailer once said he believed the United States, in its endless pursuit of war and domination, had entered a "pre-fascist era". Mailer seemed tentative, as if trying to warn about something even he could not quite define. "Fascism" is not right, for it invokes lazy historical precedents, conjuring yet again the iconography of German and Italian repression. On the other hand, American authoritarianism, as the cultural critic Henry Giroux pointed out recently, is "more nuance, less theatrical, more cunning, less concerned with repressive modes of control than with manipulative modes of consent."

This is Americanism, the only predatory ideology to deny that it is an ideology. The rise of tentacular corporations that are dictatorships in their own right and of a military that is now a state with the state, set behind the façade of the best democracy 35,000 Washington lobbyists can buy, and a popular culture programmed to divert and stultify, is without precedent."

John Pilger, Have a Nice World War, Folks

Monday, March 29, 2010 | Labels: capitalism, democracy, politics, war on terror |   3 Comments  

I like this guy...

Saturday, November 8, 2008

No, not Obama.

This guy, Davis Fleetwood:



I won’t go so far as to say that Obama’s foreign policy is equal to the Bush doctrine, but clearly there is more than “a smidgen of commonality”.

Saturday, November 08, 2008 | Labels: democracy, politics |   1 Comments  

Malcolm X on Obama

Thursday, October 30, 2008

I know I’ve been drilling this for the past few days, so I promise this will be my last post on the issue…for now. :-)

Dissident Voice has a nice article about the recent controversy surrounding Chomsky and Zinn supporting a vote for Obama. Check it out people. The writer ends the article with these strong words: "A vote for either John McCain or Barack Obama is—at best—an act of criminal negligence."

However, I was much more intrigued by the leading quote used in the article:

“You don’t stick a knife in a man’s back nine inches, and then pull it out six inches, and say you’re making progress.”
– Malcolm X


I see this as a perfect analogy representing the choice being made by anyone deciding between the two candidates. Obama supporters are essentially saying that pulling the knife out six inches is the best we can do.

I say we leave the knife all the way in until the poor sap figures out how to fight back. *That’s* the change we need!

Thursday, October 30, 2008 | Labels: democracy, Muslims, politics |   13 Comments  

Open Your Eyes

Wednesday, October 29, 2008

A commenter on my previous post asked what alternative solutions do I propose (instead of voting Obama) and I responded that third party alternatives exist, as well as countless other grassroots organizations that are struggling for real change.

I find it truly objectionable when people respond that a vote for any third party candidate is a wasted vote. Why have we accepted this predicament where only two parties are representative of the broad spectrum of the American people? Isn't that the real question? We're accepting defeat when we allow the debate to be framed between these two parties. They do NOT represent all the varying views that exist.

We need to step outside the preset parameters of the Repub-Dem debate. Its not about Obama versus McCain. Its about the masses versus the elite.

Educate yourself with this debate between presidential candidates, Ralph Nader and Chuck Baldwin. Although I don't necessarily agree on all the issues with these candidates, I stand behind any and every attempt at busting the two-party mafia that runs America.



[Youtube Link]

The real shame is that most people will never watch this debate. They need 30-sec soundbites or else their ADD kicks in.

Wednesday, October 29, 2008 | Labels: democracy, politics |   19 Comments  

The Lesser of Two Evils??

Monday, October 27, 2008

I’ve posted before on the hollowness of Obama and his campaign for ‘change’. Pigs will fly before he confronts the three-headed dragon of racism, materialism, and militarism that has wreaked havoc across the American landscape.

However, in this post I wanted to focus on another argument peddled by Muslims supporting Obama – namely, he’s the lesser of two evils.

Sorry folks, but that is such a defeatist attitude.

Instead of arguing about the need to change the crooked system that insanely refers to itself as a democracy and claims to stand for freedom and justice, American Muslims are justifying participation with this weak-minded logic of ‘lesser of two evils’.

Muslims must stand for their principles, as exemplified by our most perfect teacher (saw).

Have we forgotten how the Prophet (saw) rejected participation in the crooked Meccan political system? Did he not out-rightly reject their power-sharing deal, later responding with the famous words: Even if they (Quraish leaders of Mecca) were to place the sun in my right hand and the moon in my left, I will never join them nor will I ever desist from my message?

Then how come we are so quick to partake in an American political system that puts to shame the shenanigans of the Meccans?

I’m not arguing whether its halal or haram to partake in the political process. I’m simply talking about good ‘ol common sense.

Listen, even if the Prophet (saw) himself were standing for the President of the US, I wouldn’t vote for him. No one man can ever make a difference from within a crooked system. The Prophet understood that and that’s why he rejected participation. His struggle was to replace the rotten core - lock, stock, and barrel, instead of trying to reform it from within.

Those Muslims who are intent on exercising their right to vote by choosing the lesser of two evils would be better off focusing their energies on exposing this corporatocracy, as John Perkins of ‘Confessions of an Economic Hitman’-fame so aptly refers to it.

Simply choosing to ‘live in dignity’ as an American Muslim is burying your head in the sand ostrich-style. Simply declaring that we are ‘free’ to worship our Lord is not sufficient. Simply washing our hands of the crimes perpetrated by our adopted homeland is not sufficient.

I’m not calling for the shariah. I’m merely calling for basic justice.

The truth of the matter is that justice will be never be implemented by the current system of governance in the US. The powers-that-be will never allow for true justice to prevail. True justice has a price tag they are not willing to pay and requires a sacrifice they are not willing to make.

This is about decades of underhanded oppression that have strangled the peoples of South America, Africa, and Asia.
This is about pushing consumerism to the max, ignoring all social, economical, and environmental ramifications.
This is about supporting (and even installing) despotic regimes all over the world.
This is about the economical hamstringing of the entire Third World by the G8 countries (ingeniously using the IMF and World Bank).
This is about supporting anti-democratic forces against the democratically elected governments of Bolivia, Palestine, and Venezuela (to name a few).
This is about the cancerous banking system that has spread all over the world.
This is about a military-industry juggernaut that has wreaked global chaos with power and greed fuelling its ambitions.
This is about continuously expanding the gulf between the haves and the have-nots, within America and throughout the world.

(BTW, these injustices have taken place under the watch of both parties alike, Democrats and Republicans, so what kind of change are you expecting with Obama again?)

Confronting and ending these injustices is the change we REALLY need.

And sadly, all we American Muslims are concerned with is our ability to build Islamic schools, freely attend the local masjid, wear the hijab unharassed, and vote for Obama.

Fine, ignore the real struggle. Go ahead and claim that you’re doing your part by voting for the lesser of two evils - Just lemme know how the sand tastes down there.

Monday, October 27, 2008 | Labels: American Islam, democracy, Muslims, politics |   13 Comments  

Realities of a 'Free' Afghanistan

Saturday, August 9, 2008

It's become quite evident to even the most casual of observers that post-Taliban Afghanistan has become a miserable failure. Life for the normal Afghani is the same, if not worse. The economy is in shambles, the drug-trade is thriving, the US-puppet government has barely a hold on Kabul and a few other cities, and peace is only found in the barrel of the gun.

And then I read this story on the increasing occurrences of rape, most of which are carried out without any fear of retribution or criminal punishment.

And then I think to myself, as a father of a 10-yr old daughter, that I would rather keep my daughter holed up in my house than send her to school or work in such a lawless society.

I would happily give up these rights for the general security the Taliban had established, knowing that her trip to the local market would not end up with this most miserable of endings.

I would happily live under the 'backwards' life under Taliban rule, where my family's well-being is preserved than the 'civilized' life under US/Karzai rule, where uncontrollable beasts run the streets.

Critics (legitimately) scolded the Taliban for their oppressive ways (forcing the burqa and the beard, destroying Buddhist artifacts, shutting down girls schools, etc.), while conveniently turning a blind eye to the security and order they established in war-torn Afghanistan.

But have they provided anything better in the past 7 years?

Since when are the issues of women's rights and religious freedom even comparable to fundamental concerns for safety and security?

As lofty as their goals may have been for invading Afghanistan, they've really turned it into a cesspool of crime and corruption. Just like in Iraq, they failed to establish the most basic of societal needs – public safety. (Be sure to check out this 3-part documentary Five Years in Iraq)

I don't care to defend the Taliban, but it seriously makes my blood boil when I read articles like the CNN piece I linked above.

Sure, Afghanistan under Taliban rule was a pile of garbage, but that beats the pile of shit the US has turned it into.

I say they pack up their bags and hand the country back to the Taliban, if for no other reason but to bring back some semblance of order. Sure, the public may despise the mullahs for forcing them to wear burqas and closing down the music shops, but at least their women will be able to walk the streets without getting abducted.

Saturday, August 09, 2008 | Labels: democracy, politics |   12 Comments  

Why I can't love America

Monday, June 2, 2008

Inspired by Organic's recent post I love America, I put together these thoughts. I can't love America not for lack of trying.

I really want to love America as it’s the closest thing to a home that I have. I can't call Pakistan home as I've never lived there. And no matter how long I live here, I can never call Saudi Arabia home. So America was and has always been my only hope of having a home in this life.

But it just ain't happenin'. I can't get myself to love America.

Because America constantly thumbs her nose at international attempts at global civility. From the Kyoto treaty to the Ottowa Treaty (banning land mines) to the International Criminal Court to the latest effort to ban cluster bombs – she's proven to be a poor citizen in the neighborhood called Earth.

Because Americans so easily allow themselves to be deluded by their leaders, happily choosing to turn a blind eye and instead indulge in their opium.

Because Americans have accepted their luxuriously unsustainable standard of living no matter what the cost to the rest of the world.

Because Americans choose to constantly live beyond their means, riddling themselves with debt beyond comprehension. Crass consumerism gone wild.

Because I read Howard Zinn's "The People's History of the US", a book that every American should read.

Because I watched The Story of Stuff, a video that every American should see.

Because American democracy is a sham that it paradoxically touts as the pinnacle of human civilization.

Because the homosexual way of life is being peddled as an acceptable social norm, as opposed to relegating it to the seedy underbelly of society where it's always resided.

Because of the in-your-face hypocrisy displayed on a daily basis in the world of international politics (Saddam is evil dictator, Musharraf is good dictator).

Because American capitalism sucks. The rich keep getting richer and the poor keep getting poorer (Exxon’s first quarter profit - $11billion, Shell – $9billion...that’s profit in THREE MONTHS folks!).

Because of Gitmo Bay and the entire Chaplain James Yee fiasco (where the government unsuccessfully tried to pin adultery and porn charges on him after their initial charges of espionage and treason failed).

Because America has/had the potential to be a positive force in the world, but screwed it up.

And the list goes on...

Monday, June 02, 2008 | Labels: democracy, East meets West, politics, Western Culture |   21 Comments  

Kosova: another US Satellite State

Monday, February 25, 2008

For the past week or so, I've been trying to get a solid understanding of the Kosovo independence fiasco. I remember first learning about the Islamic heritage of the region when Muslim refugees, first from Bosnia and then from Kosova, were sponsored by Muslim communities throughout the US. Many of us perceived the decade long struggle by the Muslims (epitomized by the Kosova Liberation Army, KLA) to be a legitimate jihad against the naked aggressions of their neighboring Christians.

So when the US led its 'humanitarian' 11-week bombing campaign in 1999, almost every Muslim joined the overwhelming chorus of support that hailed it as a momentous occasion: "the tidal wave of self-adulation by respected voices, lauding the first war in history fought “in the name of principles and values,” the first bold step towards a “new era” in which the “enlightened states” will protect the human rights of all under the guiding hand of an “idealistic New World bent on ending inhumanity,” now freed from the shackles of archaic concepts of world order." Noam Chomsky

The Muslims weren't able to look beyond our religious affiliations and step back to analyze the situation objectively.

Sadly, resulting events proved that America's interference was far from humanitarian. The exaggerated calls for a second holocaust occurring in the heart of Europe were shown to be pro-war propaganda, as the mass media had clearly fallen in love with the good vs. evil story being peddled by the Clinton administration (Big bad Milosevic = Evil, Former terrorists, now freedom fighters KLA = Good). Oddly, the real genocide that had taken place just a few years before (at the time) in Rwanda wasn't worthy of any humanitarian intervention.

The Rambouillet Agreement, which was the proposed peace agreement offered to Milosevic by NATO, revealed itself to be a clear example of America looking for a satellite state in the heart of Eastern Europe, in the exact same manner that Iraq and Afghanistan have become satellite states in the Middle East and Asia. Referring to the agreement, British Lord Gilbert, defense minister of state, said, "I think the terms put to Milošević at Rambouillet were absolutely intolerable; how could he possibly accept them; it was quite deliberate."

And if there were any doubt, the ensuing construction (by a Halliburton subsidiary, no less) of a nearly 1000-acre US military base, Camp Bondsteel, exposed the real intentions of the occupying force.

Fast forward 9 years and we have Kosovo finally declaring its independence after nearly a decade of UN pseudo-occupation. What should we make of this?? I like what this brother had to say about it. Plus Safia referenced this very interesting article that coupled the recent discovery of oil and natural gas with the declaration of independence.

And if you read nothing else, read this piece at Counterpunch that provides a real good summary, drawing a chilling parallel between America's role in the Kosovo War under Clinton and its more recent Iraq War under Bush.

I really hope more people are questioning this historic event. However, I'm afraid that many are adopting the overly naive stance taken by some that since they are a nation of Muslims, we must automatically support their independence.

Merely because they are our brothers in faith does not necessitate our blind support for their questionable agenda. The wider geopolitical ramifications of their cessation must be analyzed in addition to the insidious role of the meddling US.

I can understand the ambivalent stance taken by some as the region is truly a complex smorgasbord of socio-political factors, but blind support should be out of the question. As I understand the current situation, I can't support the Kosova independence for it really doesn't bode well for the local population. And in the end, it should be about stability, peace, and justice for the people, even if it requires that Kosovo remain a province of Serbia.

Monday, February 25, 2008 | Labels: democracy, politics |   33 Comments  

Superdelegates: Good 'ol American Democracy

Tuesday, February 19, 2008

Not sure if I've shared my feelings on the American version of Democracy.

Oh yeah, I have. More than once.

Anyways, here is a nice article that provides more fuel to the fire.

As if the two-party system wasn't limiting enough in the options presented to the voters, the Democratic Party leaders are intent on dictating who that nominee should be using the superdelegates.

According to the article:

"[Walter] Mondale was quite open about the undemocratic aims of the superdelegate system. In a number of talks, he acknowledged that superdelegates were created with the explicit aim of preventing voter insurgencies."

The author goes on to quote Walter Mondale from a 1992 NY Times article:

"The election is the business of the people. But the nomination is more properly the business of the parties...The problem lies in the reforms that were supposed to open the nominating process...Party leaders have lost the power to screen candidates and select a nominee. The solution is to reduce the influence of the primaries and boost the influence of the party leaders...The superdelgate category established within the Democratic Party after 1984 allows some opportunity for this, but should be strengthened."

Do read the entire article. Worth your time to understand the lengths the power brokers will go to in order to retain control and prevent any serious change.

Tuesday, February 19, 2008 | Labels: democracy, politics |   1 Comments  

Obama vs MLK: article by Zaid Shakir

Monday, February 18, 2008

Not sure how this Zaid Shakir article totally flew under my radar, but I just read it yesterday and found it to be extremely pertinent to the current Obama lovefest.

Imam Zaid reflects on the truly revolutionary stances taken by Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. near the end of his life. In particular, he quotes one lecture Dr. King gave one year before his assassination:

"I am convinced that if we are to get on the right side of the world revolution, we as a nation must undergo a radical revolution of values. We must rapidly begin to shift from a “thing-oriented” society to a “person-oriented” society. When machines and computers, profit motives and property rights are considered more important than people, the giant triplets of racism, materialism, and militarism are incapable of being conquered..."

And then he really hits the nail on the head when he contrasts that with Obama's approach:

"Herein lays Dr. King’s legacy, an uncompromising struggle against the “giant triplets of racism, materialism and militarism.”...Obama is a viable African American candidate because he has steadfastly refused to deal with the issues Dr. King was dealing with at the end of his life, even though they are just as relevant today as they were forty years ago."

When Obama talks of change is he referring to racism or materialism or militarism? Of course not, for if he were to target those substantive issues, his fate would most definitely be in more line with that of Dr. King's:

"In the aftermath of that speech Dr. King was condemned by many African American leaders such as Whitney Young and Roy Wilkins. President Lyndon B. Johnson, who saw himself as a great friend of the “Negro” people was irate. The growing schism between Dr. King and the power structure had been cemented."

In reality, the problem is not with Obama, but with the American 'democratic' system that is so impervious to change.

Monday, February 18, 2008 | Labels: democracy, politics |   5 Comments  

I am the problem with Democracy

Wednesday, January 16, 2008

Yes, me. And others like me.

The vast majority of voters in America are simply not going to put in the required effort to educate themselves where each candidate stands on the myriad issues.

Just not gonna do it.

And that is why leaving the vote to numskulls like myself is the greatest of travesties.

The masses are so easily swayed. Votes can be manipulated, bought, or simply cast in outright ignorance.

And even those who put a semblance of effort in understanding the differences between the candidates, they are influenced by the all-powerful media which frames the discussion of the issues and the candidates (see how they're hamstringing the Kucinich campaign by excluding him from the debates).

Look at the two frontrunners in the Democratic party, Obama and Clinton. Most will agree that a vote for Clinton is a vote for the status quo. But few will admit the same of Obama.

A cursory look at his platform shows that he is a man of the establishment, for the establishment, with nary a chance of rocking the boat (h/t to gess).

Obama's team of advisors are a bunch of recycled politicians from Clinton's presidency. And one doesn't raise as much campaign funds as Obama ($80M as of last September) without serving the interests of some powerful lobbying groups in Washington. And a closer look at his foreign policy shows many similarities to that of Mitt Romney's.

I'm afraid that many Muslims will get lulled into voting for him, in the same manner that they voted for Bush 8 years ago. The man is charismatic, saying all the right things, and is promising change, yet has accomplished very little on the political scene (domestically and especially internationally).

And then there are those who are advocating voting for these Obama/Clinton based on their racial and gender minority status. (Many voted with that same spirit in the past two elections - voting for the candidate from the mentally handicapped minority group - and look where that got us?...OK, that was cheesy - couldn't help myself)

But to even suggest that a leader be elected based on gender or race is extremely ignorant. But I'm sure most votes will be cast with that being the major factor.

How pathetic.

And don't even get me started on the change-resistant nature of the two-party system. What a joke!

Let me be clear that I'm not against representational governance. I'm just fed up with all this hoopla about western-style democracy being the greatest thing since sliced bread. Lets acknowledge the absurdity of the claim that democracy is the height of man's political evolution.

Wednesday, January 16, 2008 | Labels: democracy, Divine Rememberance, Media, politics |   17 Comments  

Older Posts Home
Subscribe to: Posts (Atom)


About Me

Naeem:
Muslim married male modestly mimicking my morally impeccable model - Muhammad (saw). Here's more about me.
View my complete profile
  • Top Naeem Posts

    • My Untold Tale
    • When the Kabah spoke to me
    • Test of Faith
    • Integrating Profane with Mundane
    • Only in Mecca
    • Divine Intervention
    • The Hell with god
    • Sexual Education
    • Bandits and Lizards

    Special Posts

    • The Dig - a short story (5 parts)
    • Workout the Nafs and Qalb (3 parts)
    • Ramadan in Riyadh (4 parts)
    • Why I don't hate America
    • Why I can't love America
    • Letter to my Nafs
    • Reply from my Nafs

    Recent Posts

    Loading...

    Blog Archive

    • ▼  2016 (1)
      • ▼  November (1)
        • Trump and our misplaced fears
    • ►  2015 (2)
      • ►  November (1)
      • ►  August (1)
    • ►  2013 (5)
      • ►  November (1)
      • ►  July (2)
      • ►  April (1)
      • ►  March (1)
    • ►  2012 (8)
      • ►  September (1)
      • ►  July (1)
      • ►  May (1)
      • ►  March (2)
      • ►  February (2)
      • ►  January (1)
    • ►  2011 (36)
      • ►  December (2)
      • ►  November (3)
      • ►  October (4)
      • ►  September (1)
      • ►  August (3)
      • ►  July (2)
      • ►  June (4)
      • ►  May (3)
      • ►  April (3)
      • ►  March (3)
      • ►  February (3)
      • ►  January (5)
    • ►  2010 (40)
      • ►  December (2)
      • ►  November (1)
      • ►  August (1)
      • ►  July (1)
      • ►  June (5)
      • ►  May (5)
      • ►  April (7)
      • ►  March (8)
      • ►  February (4)
      • ►  January (6)
    • ►  2009 (72)
      • ►  December (7)
      • ►  November (6)
      • ►  October (2)
      • ►  June (1)
      • ►  May (13)
      • ►  April (12)
      • ►  March (12)
      • ►  February (8)
      • ►  January (11)
    • ►  2008 (125)
      • ►  December (12)
      • ►  November (8)
      • ►  October (7)
      • ►  September (1)
      • ►  August (6)
      • ►  July (10)
      • ►  June (12)
      • ►  May (12)
      • ►  April (15)
      • ►  March (15)
      • ►  February (13)
      • ►  January (14)
    • ►  2007 (132)
      • ►  December (13)
      • ►  November (13)
      • ►  October (14)
      • ►  September (16)
      • ►  August (20)
      • ►  July (27)
      • ►  June (21)
      • ►  May (8)

    Categories

    • Muslims (119)
    • Islam (97)
    • Spirituality (90)
    • politics (88)
    • Western Culture (66)
    • war on nafs (66)
    • American Islam (57)
    • Humor (54)
    • social problems (44)
    • war on terror (44)
    • Divine Rememberance (42)
    • life in Saudi Arabia (42)
    • raising kids (34)
    • Media (28)
    • East meets West (26)
    • Pakistan (26)
    • web stuff (22)
    • capitalism (18)
    • About Me (16)
    • Palestine (16)
    • Modernity (15)
    • democracy (15)
    • Good News Post (14)
    • Shariah (12)
    • Taliban (11)
    • clash of civilizations (11)
    • married life (11)
    • Africa (6)
    • Islamic State (5)
    • Jihad (5)
    • Obama (4)
    • Egypt (3)
    • Shabab (3)
    • Prophetic Love (2)
    • Chavez (1)
    • End Times (1)
    • Humza's Fashion (1)
    • Quranic discoveries (1)
    • anti-Semitism (1)
    • homeschooling (1)

    Saudi Blogs

    • Al-Miskeenah
    • American Bedu
    • Crossroads Arabia
    • Susie's Big Adventure

    Sites of Interest

    • Al-Madina Institute
    • CommonDreams
    • CounterPunch
    • ImanWire
    • Muslim Alltop
    • MuslimMatters
    • Real News Network
    • Seeker's Digest
    • Tabsir
  • Subscribe via email

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    Recent Comments

    ↑ Want this widget?

    BlogRoll

    • Darvish
      Except by Him
      2 weeks ago
    • Indigo Jo Blogs
      When racists become disability activists
      2 weeks ago
    • MUSLIMOLOGY.ORG
      Deep Dive into the Surah al-Isra Prophecies
      1 year ago
    • ASHRAFIYA
      Request for dua & esal-e-thawab
      1 year ago
    • Azra's Adventures
      A rose by any other name...
      8 years ago
    • Contemplations of a Stranger
      Ramadan 1438 Parting Prayer
      9 years ago
    • cambridge khutbas etc.
      The People of Harmony
      10 years ago
    • Dunner's
      Holy Switch
      11 years ago
    • |-| Fajr |-|
    • Mozaffar's Moments

    Misc


Copyright 2008 Free Premium Wordpress Themes and BlackQuanta | Bloggerized by : GosuBlogger